Aims and Scope
Economics is an open-access journal that does not charge any author fees. This is due to support by its founding institutions, the Kiel Institute for World Economy and the ZBW – Leibniz Information Centre for Economics. Both institutions belong to the Leibniz Association. Jointly, they launched the Economics in 2007, and at that time, they also agreed to finance it.
economics is a new type of academic journal in economics. By involving a large research community in an innovative public peer review process, economics aims to provide fast access to top-quality papers. Modern communication technologies are used to find for every research issue the best virtual team out of a network of highly motivated researchers from all over the world. Thus, publishing is seen as a cooperative enterprise between authors, editors, referees, and readers. economics offers open access to all readers and takes the form of an e-journal, i.e. submission, evaluation, and publication are electronic.
economics embodies the following principles:
Open Access: Following the principle that knowledge is a public good, the journal adheres to the BOAI definition of open access: that users have the right to "read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of these articles".
Open Assessment: The traditional peer review process is substantially supplemented by a public peer review process in which the community of active researchers from all over the world has a hand in the evaluation process. Due to interactive peer review and public discussion, economics provides fast and efficient quality assurance. Within a two stage publication process, much of the research evaluation takes place after rather than before an article is published. Prizes for the most outstanding papers in special fields are awarded.
Speed: Submitted papers that have been identified as sufficiently promising for a referee process are made available on the journal’s homepage within three weeks. Thus, the time for new ideas to find their way into the scientific community is substantially reduced.
Add-on Services: To foster scientific exchange, economics embeds forums on special themes, where authors and readers can communicate and possibly conduct joint research. In addition, interested readers can take advantage of alert services announcing new papers in their fields. As far as possible, economics also provides hyperlinks to the referenced literature.
Style and Contents
economics aims to cover all the main areas of economics. Inevitably, articles in different areas of economics are addressed at different audiences. Many of the articles submitted to the journal are standard technical pieces, addressed to a purely academic audience. Others concern economic policy and thus are addressed both to economists and policy makers with some economic background. Yet others are surveys and overviews, often interdisciplinary, addressed to a non-technical audience. To attract this variety of contributions, economics will contain the following areas, in addition to the standard contributions for a purely academic audience:
economics Policy Papers are concerned with the economic analysis of current policy issues. The analysis is rigorous, from a theoretical and empirical perspective, but the articles are written in non-technical language appropriate for a broad spectrum of economic decision makers and participants economic policy discussion.
Surveys and Overviews
Surveys and Overviews aim to integrate the analysis and lessons from various fields of economics with the aim of providing new insights, that are not accessible from any particular sub-discipline of economics. The contributions may include survey and review articles, provided that the broad perspective is maintained. They are addressed to a general audience interested in economic issues.
A replication is a study whose primary purpose is to confirm the validity of a previously published study. A replication will generally consist of two parts. The first part is an attempt to reproduce key findings from the original study. In this exercise, the replicating author will ideally attempt to exactly reproduce the original study’s findings using the identical data set. If the replicating author is initially unsuccessful in this exercise, it is expected that they will contact the original author to gain their assistance in this exercise. In the event that a replication study is successful at reproducing the original study, the next part should consist of a robustness check, if possible. This can be done through a variety of means such as estimating alternative variable specifications, using new data, and/or applying appropriate, alternative estimation procedures. The journal is committed to publishing both confirming and disconfirming replications. The only criterion is that the replication be done to a high standard of professional competency.